Living here
Insurance agencies in the towns around Madison
Many Dane County towns have their own insurance offices, some tied to a single company and some independent. These agencies from our directory are grouped by town, each noted by its company affiliation and the kinds of coverage it offers.
Checked against official sources · Updated November 17, 2026
Cottage Grove
- Alejandra Bustamante State Farm Cottage Grove: State Farm office on West Cottage Grove Road covering auto, home, renters, business, life and health, including Medicare supplements. Service is offered in English, Spanish and Hmong.
- Farmers Insurance - Christopher Chandler: Farmers Insurance agent on Southing Grange for auto, home, renters, condo, life, business, motorcycle and umbrella coverage.
- Wilson Independence Insurance Agency: Independent agency on West Cottage Grove Road working with several carriers, for auto, home, life, business, umbrella, motorcycle and recreational vehicle insurance.
For the area, see things to do in Cottage Grove.
Cross Plains and Mount Horeb
- Jim Dietzen - State Farm Cross Plains: State Farm office on Bourbon Road in Cross Plains covering auto, home, condo, renters, business, life, RV and boat insurance.
- Jim Dietzen - State Farm Mount Horeb: State Farm office on Springdale Street in Mount Horeb, serving Dane and Iowa counties with auto, home, renters, business, life and health coverage.
For the area, see things to do in Mount Horeb and things to do in Cross Plains.
Fitchburg
- American Family Insurance - Christina Gallagher Agency: American Family Insurance agency with offices in Fitchburg, Lodi and Poynette, offering car, home, life, renters, umbrella and small business coverage.
- Katie Riley - State Farm Insurance Agent: State Farm office on Triverton Pike Drive serving Fitchburg, Oregon, Verona and Stoughton, with auto, home, renters, business, life and pet coverage.
For the area, see things to do in Fitchburg.
McFarland
- Andrew Peart American Family Insurance: American Family Insurance agency on Larson Beach Road offering car, home, life, renters, umbrella and small business coverage.
- Farmers Insurance - Michael Chandler McFarland: Farmers Insurance office on Triangle Street, with a second office in Stoughton, for auto, home, renters, condo, life, business and umbrella coverage.
For the area, see things to do in McFarland.
Middleton
- AAA Madison West: AAA branch on Deming Way with auto, home, life, renters, umbrella and flood insurance alongside membership and travel services.
- Dan Pechauer - State Farm Insurance: State Farm office at University Avenue and Park Street covering auto, home, renters, life, Medicare supplement, supplemental health and small business insurance.
- Jeff Engelkes Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance: American Family Insurance agency on North High Point Road for car, home, renters, life, umbrella and small business coverage.
For the area, see things to do in Middleton.
Monona
- Farmers Insurance - April Carlisle: Farmers Insurance office on Monona Drive for auto, home, renters, condo, life, business and umbrella coverage.
- Jeff Jacobson - COUNTRY Financial: COUNTRY Financial office on Frost Woods Drive with car, home, life, farm and business insurance.
For the area, see things to do in Monona.
Oregon
- Cathy Gilbertson - State Farm Insurance Agent: State Farm office on Janesville Street offering auto, home, condo, renters, life, health, business and pet insurance.
- Ryan Gerharz - State Farm Insurance Agent: State Farm office on North Main Street serving Oregon, Fitchburg, Stoughton and nearby communities with auto, home, renters, business, life, health and pet coverage.
For the area, see things to do in Oregon.
Stoughton
- Abbey Welsh State Farm: State Farm office on Jackson Street serving Stoughton, Oregon, McFarland and Cottage Grove, with auto, home, renters, business, life, pet, RV and boat coverage.
- Farmers Insurance - Michael Chandler Stoughton: Farmers Insurance agency on East Main Street, with a second office in McFarland, for auto, home, renters, condo, business, life and umbrella coverage.
For the area, see things to do in Stoughton.
Sun Prairie
- Adept Insurance Group: Independent agency focused on health, life and disability coverage, including Medicare supplement insurance.
- Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent: State Farm office on East Main Street for auto, home, condo, renters, life, business and pet insurance, with service in English and Spanish.
- Farmers Insurance - Matthew Johnson: Farmers Insurance office on North Bristol Street covering auto, home, renters, condo, life, business and umbrella insurance.
- Monica Titley: Allstate Insurance: Allstate agency on West Main Street for home, auto, condo, renters, life and business insurance.
For the area, see things to do in Sun Prairie.
Waunakee and DeForest
- Affordable Insurance Solutions: Independent agency on Baker Street working with several carriers, including Erie Insurance, for homeowners, renters, auto, umbrella, boat, business and farm coverage.
- Casey Colerick - Farmers Insurance: Farmers Insurance office on West Main Street for auto, home, renters, condo, life, business and umbrella coverage.
- HUB International Waunakee: HUB International office on Progress Way for business, workers' compensation, employee benefits and personal insurance, with a focus on farm and agribusiness.
- John Jensen - State Farm Insurance Agent: State Farm office on Stephenson Lane for auto, home, condo, renters, business, life, health and pet insurance.
- The Lea Agency - American Family Insurance Waunakee: American Family Insurance agency with offices in Waunakee and DeForest, for car, home, renters, life, umbrella and commercial coverage.
For the area, see things to do in Waunakee and things to do in DeForest.
Before you choose
Whichever office you pick, confirm that the agent and the insurance company are both licensed in Wisconsin. The state Office of the Commissioner of Insurance offers license lookups and takes consumer complaints, and our insurance guide walks through both. For agencies in Madison itself, see insurance agents in Madison and insurance agencies in Madison by area, or browse the full insurance agents category.
Tips from readers
Know something that would help a neighbor? Be the first to share a tip.
Keep reading
Sources
Rules and dates can change. Check the official source before you rely on them, and suggest a correction if something is out of date.
- Alejandra Bustamante State Farm Cottage Grove
- Farmers Insurance - Christopher Chandler
- Wilson Independence Insurance Agency
- Jim Dietzen - State Farm Cross Plains
- Jim Dietzen - State Farm Mount Horeb
- American Family Insurance - Christina Gallagher Agency
- Katie Riley - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Andrew Peart American Family Insurance
- Farmers Insurance - Michael Chandler McFarland
- AAA Madison West
- Dan Pechauer - State Farm Insurance
- Jeff Engelkes Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance
- Farmers Insurance - April Carlisle
- Jeff Jacobson - COUNTRY Financial
- Cathy Gilbertson - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Ryan Gerharz - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Abbey Welsh State Farm
- Farmers Insurance - Michael Chandler Stoughton
- Adept Insurance Group
- Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Farmers Insurance - Matthew Johnson
- Monica Titley: Allstate Insurance
- Affordable Insurance Solutions
- Casey Colerick - Farmers Insurance
- HUB International Waunakee
- John Jensen - State Farm Insurance Agent
- The Lea Agency - American Family Insurance Waunakee