Living here
Buying insurance in Madison
Insurance rules in Wisconsin are set and enforced by a state agency, and most of the useful consumer tools are free. This guide points to those tools and explains a few distinctions that trip people up, such as flood coverage and the two kinds of agents. It doesn't compare policies or companies.
Checked against official sources · Updated November 15, 2026
What the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance does
The Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI) licenses and oversees the insurance companies and agents doing business in the state, takes consumer complaints and publishes consumer guides. Its general consumer line is 800-236-8517.
OCI's life-stage pages cover early adulthood, newlyweds, new parents, new homeowners, job changes and retirement, and it publishes guides on homeowners and auto insurance. Two points from that guide are worth knowing: auto and homeowners premiums can change within 60 days of purchase, and Wisconsin health and life policies have a 10- or 30-day free-look period to return a policy for a refund.
Check an agent's license before you buy
OCI's lookup page offers two searches, both run through a National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) portal:
- An agent or health insurance navigator. Set the jurisdiction to Wisconsin, the search type to Licensee and the entity type to Individual, then search by name or license number.
- A company. Set the jurisdiction to Wisconsin and the search type to Company, then search by company name.
The NAIC also advises making sure that both the agent and the insurance company are licensed in your state. If you can't find a person or company, OCI asks you to call its line at 800-236-8517. OCI also notes that discount plans aren't insurance and aren't regulated by OCI.
Independent and captive agents
The NAIC describes the difference this way. An independent agent may sell policies from many different companies, so you can compare carriers. A captive agent, also called a direct agent, sells insurance for only one company. Both work for the insurers whose policies they sell and are paid commissions by those insurers.
What matters is that the coverage fits your situation and that the agent and company are both licensed.
If something goes wrong: complaints
OCI says to contact the insurer or agent first and ask them to fix the problem, and to keep records of all communications. If that doesn't work, you can file a complaint with OCI online, or download a PDF form and send it in. OCI handles complaints about health, life and annuity, and property and casualty insurers and their agents. It can't handle employer self-funded health plans, Medicare, BadgerCare Plus or policies bought in another state.
OCI sends your complaint to the company, which must explain its actions, and reviews the response for compliance with Wisconsin law and your policy. It can't give legal advice, value a claim or order a payment if the company followed the law and the policy. Include the company name, policy and claim numbers and copies of supporting documents. OCI warns that submitted information may become a public record once the file closes, so remove Social Security numbers. For claim disputes of $10,000 or less, OCI's page says you may consider small claims court.
Auto and renter's insurance
Wisconsin sets minimum auto liability limits. Our owning a car guide lists the OCI minimums. Your landlord's policy covers the building, not your belongings, so see our renting guide for what a renter's policy generally covers.
Flood damage is a separate policy
OCI explains that a standard homeowners policy generally covers water coming from the top down but not water coming from the bottom up. Seepage through the foundation and overland flow aren't covered and need a separate flood policy. Sewer backup and sump pump overflow are excluded from both and need a special endorsement. FEMA's FloodSmart site agrees that most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage.
Flood coverage is available through the federally backed National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) in participating communities, and OCI says it generally has a 30-day waiting period from purchase. FEMA's FloodSmart site lets you buy an NFIP policy online and has a tool for finding an insurance provider.
To see whether a Madison property is in a FEMA floodplain, the City of Madison points to the FEMA Map Service Center, which it calls the official repository of flood insurance rate maps. Search the address there. For floodplain management or map questions, the city's Zoning office is at 608-266-4551. We cover this in an Ask answer too: how to find out if a property is in a floodplain.
Health insurance marketplace basics
HealthCare.gov lists open enrollment for 2027 coverage as November 1 to January 15. To have coverage start January 1, enroll or change plans by December 15 and pay your first premium. Plans chosen December 16 through January 15 start February 1 once the first premium is paid. After open enrollment ends, you generally need a Special Enrollment Period to sign up.
For free help, Covering Wisconsin, a program of the UW-Madison Division of Extension, describes its service as free help signing up for health insurance through HealthCare.gov and BadgerCare Plus. Call 608-261-1455 or 877-942-6837, or use the Find help near me link on its site. OCI also cautions against giving your Social Security, bank or card numbers just to get a health insurance quote.
Medicare help
Wisconsin's State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) offers free, confidential Medicare counseling. The Department of Health Services says counselors don't sell anything and aren't paid by any company or plan. The Wisconsin Medigap Helpline (800-242-1060), run by the Board on Aging and Long Term Care, covers Medicare supplement insurance, Medicare Advantage plans, employer-based insurance and long-term care insurance. The Board says its counselors hold Wisconsin life and health insurance licenses and aren't tied to any company, so they can't endorse one insurer over another. For other services for older adults, see our senior resources guide.
Independent agencies in our directory
These agencies call themselves independent on their own sites. The list is alphabetical, it's a sample and it isn't a ranking. Browse all insurance agents in the directory, and check any agent's license with OCI's lookup first.
- Cliff Insurance Agency (West Beltline, Madison): serving Madison since 1956, with auto, home, renters, motorcycle, business and life coverage.
- Esch Insurance Agency (Mount Horeb): founded in Dodgeville in 1959, with personal, farm and business lines and a Mount Horeb office on Springdale Street.
- Greene-Niesen Insurance Agency (University Avenue, Middleton): lists personal lines including flood and umbrella coverage, business insurance and bonds.
- Med-Care Senior Insurance (DeForest): independent agents helping Wisconsin seniors with Medicare Advantage, supplement and Part D plans.
- Prairie Land Insurance Agency (Atwood Avenue, Madison): personal and business insurance, including farm, contractor and nonprofit coverage.
For wider money planning, see our financial advisors.
Tips from readers
Know something that would help a neighbor? Be the first to share a tip.
Keep reading
Sources
Rules and dates can change. Check the official source before you rely on them, and suggest a correction if something is out of date.
- OCI: Buying insurance online (PI-220)
- OCI: Look up an agent or company
- OCI: Look-up page
- OCI: Filing a complaint
- OCI: Insurance resources for every stage of life
- OCI: Auto and vehicle insurance
- OCI: Consumer's guide to homeowners insurance (PI-015)
- OCI: Flood damage (PI-240)
- NAIC: How to choose an insurance agent
- FloodSmart (FEMA): Flood insurance
- City of Madison: FEMA general information
- HealthCare.gov: Dates and deadlines
- Covering Wisconsin
- Wisconsin DHS: SHIP Medicare counseling
- Board on Aging and Long Term Care: Medigap Helpline
- Cliff Insurance Agency
- Esch Insurance Agency
- Greene-Niesen Insurance Agency
- Med-Care Senior Insurance
- Prairie Land Insurance Agency