Skip to content

Living here

Insurance agencies in Madison by area

A nearby office can make it easier to stop in or meet in person. The agencies below from our directory are grouped by area, each noted as an independent agency or one representing a named company, with the kinds of coverage it offers. Our insurance agents guide covers more agencies, and our insurance guide explains how Wisconsin licenses agents and handles complaints. Browse every office under insurance agents. For agencies in Sun Prairie, Middleton, Waunakee and other nearby towns, see insurance agencies in the towns around Madison.

Checked against official sources · Updated November 17, 2026

Downtown

East side

  • Stokes & Associates: American Family Insurance agency on Atwood Avenue offering car, home, renters, life and umbrella insurance plus small business coverage.
  • Gehrke Insurance Agency: Mendota Street agency that offers auto, renters, motorcycle, boat, RV, snowmobile and commercial auto coverage through Progressive.

West side

  • Kevin Lease, State Farm: State Farm office near Mineral Point and Gammon roads that has served the west side since 2000, with auto, home, renters, business, life and health lines.
  • Michael Wegner, State Farm: State Farm agent on Grand Canyon Drive. The office speaks English and Spanish and has step-free access and parking behind the building.
  • Michael Kittoe, American Family: American Family Insurance agent on Junction Road, with car, home, renters, life and umbrella insurance, bundles and small business coverage.
  • Thomas Bradley Insurance: Independent agency on Fourier Drive serving Madison and south-central Wisconsin since 2011, representing carriers such as Acuity, Badger Mutual, Nationwide, Secura and Wisconsin Mutual.

South side and Fitchburg

  • Alex Rabb, State Farm: Second-generation State Farm agent on South Park Street, with auto, home, renters, life, health (including Medicare supplement) and small business lines.
  • Ace Insurance Group: Independent agency on Seminole Centre Court that places coverage with many carriers, including Acuity, West Bend, Secura and Progressive.
  • Belle & Heth Insurance Agency: Independent agency on Seminole Centre Court that represents Erie Insurance among its carriers, with home, auto, renters, umbrella and life coverage.
  • Brett Gerharz, State Farm: Second-generation State Farm agent on Nesbitt Road, serving Fitchburg, Madison, Verona, Stoughton and Oregon.
  • Goosehead Insurance, Bex Laird: Goosehead Insurance agent on Marketplace Drive who compares policies from dozens of carriers. Service is in English and Portuguese.

North side

  • Cheng Vang, State Farm: State Farm agent on North Sherman Avenue who speaks English, Hmong and Laotian.
  • Debra Armstrong, Farmers: Farmers Insurance agent on North Sherman Avenue serving Madison, Monona, Middleton, Waunakee and Sun Prairie.

Middleton

  • Aaron Achenbach, State Farm: Third-generation State Farm agent whose office at Park Street and University Avenue has served the area since 1950.
  • The Health Insurance Store: Run by Becker Agency on University Avenue, with Medicare, individual and family, and employer group health plans from several insurance companies.
  • The BenefitWorks: Independent employee-benefits firm working with more than 40 national carriers on group health, life and disability coverage and ACA compliance.

Monona and McFarland

  • CFL Financial: Independent agency on Monona Drive with auto, home, renters, life, motorcycle and RV coverage, plus commercial lines.
  • Julie Bass, State Farm: State Farm agent on Monona Drive since 2006, serving Madison, Monona, McFarland and Cottage Grove.
  • The Insurance Center: Multi-office Wisconsin agency based in Onalaska, with a Monona Drive office, covering business, individual and farm and agriculture needs.

Sun Prairie

  • Homewood Insurance Agency: Independent agency on West Main Street since 1989, representing carriers including Acuity, Progressive, Secura and West Bend.
  • Rusch Insurance: Independent agency on Commercial Avenue serving Sun Prairie, Madison, Windsor, DeForest and Cottage Grove, with auto, home, life, health, Medicare, business and group benefits coverage.
  • Rural Mutual, Mitch Deprey: Multi-line Rural Mutual agent on West Main Street with farm and agriculture, business, auto, home and life insurance.
  • Titley Insurance Group: Allstate agency on West Main Street, established in 2014, with homeowners, auto, life, renters, condo and business insurance.

Verona

  • Sarah Drew, State Farm: State Farm agent with offices on East Verona Avenue and in New Glarus, with auto, home, renters, business, life, health and pet insurance.

Waunakee

  • WIA Insurance: Independent agency on South Century Avenue with a second office in Middleton, working with carriers such as Acuity, Erie, Progressive and Secura.
  • Troy Salisbury, State Farm: State Farm agent on East Main Street since 2008, with auto, home, renters and life lines.

Stoughton

  • Potter Insurance Associates: Independent agency on South Gjertson Street licensed in Wisconsin, Iowa, Illinois and Minnesota and serving Edgerton, Janesville, Madison, McFarland and Oregon.
  • Ruth Ann Murphy, State Farm: State Farm agent on East Main Street since 1993, with auto, home, renters, business, life, health and pet insurance.

Oregon

  • Abell Insurance Agency: Independent agency on Janesville Street that specializes in Erie Insurance and also writes Foremost and Progressive.
  • Torhorst Insurance: Independent agency on North Main Street representing carriers such as Acuity, Badger Mutual, Liberty Mutual and Progressive.
  • SG Insurance Agency: Independent agency on Alpine Parkway serving Madison, McFarland, Stoughton, Sun Prairie and Verona, with personal and business lines.

DeForest and other towns

  • Jim Miller, State Farm: State Farm agent in DeForest since 2004, at Main and Murray streets, with auto, home, Medicare supplement and business lines.
  • The Lea Agency: American Family Insurance agency with offices in DeForest and Waunakee, offering car, home, renters, life and umbrella insurance and commercial lines.
  • Greater Insurance Service: Multi-carrier agency headquartered on South Main Street in Cottage Grove, with offices across Wisconsin and auto, home, farm, life, health and flood coverage.

More insurance agents in Madison by area

More insurance agents in nearby towns

Before you choose an office

Whichever office you pick, check the agent's license first. Our Ask answer on how to check an insurance agent's license in Wisconsin explains the state lookup, and the license applies to agents anywhere in Wisconsin.

  • Wisconsin sets minimum auto liability limits for every driver. See what car insurance is required in Wisconsin.
  • If a claim goes wrong, see how to file a complaint against an insurance company.

Agencies change offices, carriers and lines of coverage, so confirm details with the office directly.

Tips from readers

Know something that would help a neighbor? Be the first to share a tip.

Share a tip

Keep reading

Sources

Rules and dates can change. Check the official source before you rely on them, and suggest a correction if something is out of date.