Living here
Insurance agents in Madison
Insurance in Madison is sold mostly through local offices, from one-person agencies to regional firms. A sample of agents from our directory is grouped below by how they sell: independent agencies that can quote several companies, captive agents who represent a single company, and specialists in Medicare, health and business insurance. The sample isn't a ranking or a recommendation, and policies aren't compared. For how Wisconsin regulates agents, flood coverage and complaints, see our insurance guide, and browse every office under insurance agents. For more agencies grouped by neighborhood and town, see insurance agencies by area.
Checked against official sources · Updated November 17, 2026
Independent agencies
An independent agency can place coverage with more than one company, so you can ask for quotes from several. These are grouped by town.
Madison
- Cliff Insurance Agency is on West Beltline Highway and has served Madison since 1956. A second office is in Darlington.
- Baer Insurance Services is on Brader Way and has served the community for more than 90 years, with personal, business and benefits coverage.
- Prairie Land Insurance Agency is on Atwood Avenue and serves personal and business clients.
- In Control Insurance is on South Yellowstone Drive and offers personal, commercial, farm and flood coverage from multiple carriers.
- Mc Adler Insurance Agency is on Junction Road and has access to hundreds of carriers for home, auto, life, disability and business insurance.
- Wisconsin Financial Services is on Corporate Drive and writes with 17 companies. It also offers tax preparation and notary services.
Middleton
- Greene-Niesen Insurance Agency is on University Avenue. It compares many carriers and offers home, auto, business and surety bonds.
Surrounding towns
- Glen Oaks Insurance Group in Cottage Grove is on Landmark Drive and works with Badger Mutual, West Bend and other carriers, including for farms.
- Endres Insurance Agency in Cross Plains was founded in 1985 and covers farms, trucking and businesses.
- Verona Insurance Agency is locally owned and in downtown Verona's Historic District, with auto, SR-22, home and life coverage.
- PWA Insurance Group in Mount Horeb is locally owned, was founded in 2017 and works with more than 15 carriers.
- Evolve Insurance Solutions in Stoughton is veteran-owned and works with Travelers, Acuity and other carriers.
Captive agents for one company
A captive agent represents a single insurer, such as State Farm, American Family, Farmers, Allstate, COUNTRY Financial or Rural Mutual. If you already have a policy with one of these companies, an office nearby can be convenient. Agents here are listed by company.
State Farm
- Aaron Perry has an office on Monroe Street in Madison and more than 20 years in insurance.
- Dawn Goplin has had an office on Junction Road in Madison since 2004, with service in Spanish.
American Family Insurance
- Aune & Associates is on Donofrio Drive in Madison and offers car, home, life and small business coverage.
- Carlos Chacon has an office on Greenway Cross in Madison, with service in English and Spanish.
- Cha & Associates is across from Nakoma Park in Madison, with service in English and Hmong.
Farmers Insurance
- Peter Arttus is on Struck Street in Madison and has more than 40 years with Farmers.
Allstate
- Wenzel Agency is on East Towne Boulevard in Madison and opened in 2012.
COUNTRY Financial and Rural Mutual
- Tom Bader has a COUNTRY Financial office on Terrace Court in Madison for insurance, retirement and college savings.
- Garrett Goldsmith has a Rural Mutual office on Arboretum Drive in Waunakee, with farm, business, auto, home and life coverage.
Many more State Farm, American Family and Farmers offices are in Fitchburg, Middleton, Monona, Oregon, Stoughton, Sun Prairie, Verona and elsewhere. They're all listed under insurance agents.
Medicare, health and other specialties
Some agents focus on one kind of insurance.
- Med-Care Senior Insurance in DeForest has independent agents who help Wisconsin seniors with Medicare Advantage, supplement and Part D plans.
- Frank Insurance Group is on Big Sky Drive in Madison and focuses on Medicare, including Medicare Supplement and Part D help.
- Prairie Grove Insurance is on Voges Road in Madison and works with more than 25 insurers, focused on Medicare Supplement and Advantage plans.
- Aria Benefits is a health insurance agency founded in 2016, with individual, ACA, group, Medicare and small-business coverage. Its Madison office is on Big Sky Drive.
- Health Choice on Donofrio Drive in Madison markets long-term care insurance and has served State of Wisconsin and UW employees and retirees since 1995.
- Ansay & Associates is a Wisconsin-based independent agency with an office on West Beltline Highway, offering business and personal insurance, employee benefits and risk management.
- McClone Insurance is a family-owned Wisconsin firm with a West Beltline Highway office, focused on business insurance and benefits.
- Compliance Insurance is an independent Middleton agency founded in 1988 that handles high-risk auto and SR-22 filings and serves all of Wisconsin.
- Action Insurance Agency on West Beltline Highway in Madison also handles high-risk auto and SR-22 filings.
For help beyond sales, our senior resources guide covers other services for older adults.
Questions to ask an agent
Whichever type of agent you choose, these neutral questions can help you compare offices:
- Are you independent, or do you represent one company? If independent, which companies do you work with?
- Which companies would quote my situation, and who handles a claim if I need to file one?
- Who is my day-to-day contact, and how do I reach the office with a question?
- Can you put the coverages, limits and deductibles in writing so I can read them before I decide?
- What would change my policy at renewal, and how will I be notified?
- If I move or my needs change, do I need to start over?
Check an agent's license before you buy: our Ask answer on how to check an insurance agent's license in Wisconsin explains the state lookup.
Related guides
- Buying a home: see our buying a home guide for the home-buying process.
- Cars: our owning a car guide covers the state's auto insurance basics.
- Renting: our renting guide covers renter's insurance.
- Flood coverage: see how to get flood insurance for a Madison home.
- Car insurance: see what car insurance is required in Wisconsin.
- Problems with a claim: see how to file a complaint against an insurance company.
Tips from readers
Know something that would help a neighbor? Be the first to share a tip.
Keep reading
Sources
Rules and dates can change. Check the official source before you rely on them, and suggest a correction if something is out of date.
- OCI: Look up an agent or company
- NAIC: How to choose an insurance agent
- Cliff Insurance Agency
- Baer Insurance Services
- Prairie Land Insurance Agency
- In Control Insurance
- MC Adler Insurance Agency & Financial Services
- Wisconsin Financial Services
- Greene-Niesen Insurance Agency
- Glen Oaks Insurance Group
- Endres Insurance Agency
- Verona Insurance Agency
- PWA Insurance Group
- Evolve Insurance Solutions
- Aaron Perry - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Dawn Goplin - State Farm Insurance
- Aune & Associates
- Carlos Chacon American Family Insurance
- Cha and Associates, Inc. American Family Insurance
- Farmers Insurance - Arttus Agency
- Wenzel Agency - Allstate
- Tom Bader - COUNTRY Financial
- Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Garrett Goldsmith
- Med-Care Senior Insurance
- Frank Insurance Group
- Prairie Grove Insurance
- Aria Benefits
- HealthChoice Insurance Solutions
- Ansay & Associates
- McClone Insurance
- Compliance Insurance
- Action Insurance Agency