Skip to content

Eat & drink

Pizza in Madison, WI: slices, wood-fired, Detroit-style and tavern pies

Madison is a pizza town: Rocky Rococo started here in 1974, Ian's made the mac and cheese slice famous, and there's a wood-fired oven in most neighborhoods. This guide sorts the local spots by style. Every place was confirmed open on its own site or ordering page in November 2026, and the pies named come from each menu.

Checked against official sources · Updated November 1, 2026

By the slice

  • Ian's Pizza (100 State St., 319 N. Frances St., Garver Feed Mill and Verona): big slices, including the Mac n' Cheese and Smokey the Bandit. Ian's opened on Halloween night 2001. Build-your-own pies can use a 12-inch gluten-free crust, and there are vegan toppings.
  • Eat the Best Pizza (711 State St.): New York-style slices, including stuffed slices, plus a Sicilian deep dish and a gluten-free cheese pizza.

Wood-fired and Neapolitan

  • Pizza Brutta (1805 Monroe St.): Neapolitan-inspired pies from a wood oven, split into rossa (red) and bianca (white), like the Margherita con Bufala. Gluten-free crust is available.
  • Bar Corallini (2004 Atwood Ave.): wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizza with house-made mozzarella, including mortadella e burrata, a gluten-sensitive crust and vegan pies.
  • Naples 15 (15 N. Butler St.): Neapolitan pizzas from a wood oven, each named after a Neapolitan song.
  • Novanta (8452 Old Sauk Rd., far west side): Neapolitan pies like the Diavola from Italian-made ovens that run at 900 degrees and up; delivery and carryout.
  • Lucille (101 King St.): wood-fired round pies like The Queen, plus Detroit-inspired steel pan pizzas made with local cheddar.

Detroit-style, tomato pies and tavern-style

  • Molten Monkey (912 E. Johnson St.): Detroit-style squares with caramelized cheese corners, like the What up Dough; several come in vegan versions. Order online for carryout or delivery.
  • Salvatore's Tomato Pies (10 N. Livingston St.; 5507 Monona Dr., Monona; 121 E. Main St., Sun Prairie): tomato pies, like the Tomato Pie with Basil, and the Figgy Piggy, plus take-and-bake frozen pies. "All Wisco, no Sysco."
  • Greenbush Bar (914 Regent St.): 16-inch tavern-style thin crust in the speakeasy-style basement of the Italian Workmen's Club, serving pizza since 1993 and open until midnight. Tavern-style pizza is thin and cracker-crisp, cut into squares (a "party cut") instead of wedges.
  • Luigi's Pizza (515 S. Midvale Blvd.): hand-stretched thin crust, like the Il Capo, with gluten-sensitive, vegan and cauliflower crusts.
  • Grampa's Pizzeria (1374 Williamson St.): artisanal thin-crust pies with names like the Brassacre and the Jabroni.

Neighborhood favorites and delivery

  • Glass Nickel Pizza Co. (2916 Atwood Ave., plus University Ave., Fitchburg and Sun Prairie): opened on Atwood in 1997; known for the Thai Pie and Fetalicious, with gluten-free and vegan options and its own delivery drivers.
  • Rocky Rococo (1618 W. Beltline Hwy., Monona Dr. and DeForest): pan-style pizza from the chain that started on Gilman Street in 1974.
  • Pizza Pit (Atlas Ct. on the far east side, Sun Prairie, Stoughton and Oregon): a delivery pizzeria with super thin, thin or thick crusts and a Mac-n-Cheese pie.
  • Rosati's (4933 Commercial Ave.): Chicago-style deep dish and tavern thin crust.

Around the area

  • Waunakee: Zoe's Pizzeria (604 E. Main St.), hand-tossed and Detroit pan pizza, with a gluten-free 10-inch thin crust and a plant-based menu.
  • Stoughton: Famous Yeti's Pizza, crispy thin and stuffed pizzas (like the Yeti Spaghetti) and slices.
  • Verona: Sugar River Pizza Company (957 Liberty Dr.), a scratch-made neighborhood pizzeria; Ian's also has a Verona store with 12 rotating taps.
  • Breweries with pizza: The Lone Girl Taproom (1817 E. Washington Ave.) bakes Roman-style pizza on a 72-hour dough. See our breweries guide for more.

Browse every pizza place in the directory, or see where to eat in Madison.

Tips from readers

Know something that would help a neighbor? Be the first to share a tip.

Share a tip

Keep reading

Sources

Rules and dates can change. Check the official source before you rely on them, and suggest a correction if something is out of date.