Skip to content

Eat & drink

Sandwiches and delis in Madison

A good sandwich in Madison can mean a meatball sub from an Italian deli that has been around since 1971, a New York-style bagel with lox, or a tater tot wrap after a night on State Street. This guide groups the independent delis and sandwich shops in our directory by style and area. Menus change, so check a shop's site or call before you go. For the full list, browse sandwiches and delis in Madison.

Checked against official sources · Updated November 15, 2026

Italian and traditional delis

  • Fraboni's Italian Specialties & Delicatessen, 108 Owen Rd., Monona: "a Madison tradition since 1971," per its site. Sandwiches include meatball with marinara, porketta, Italian sausage with sauteed peppers and onions, and BBQ or pulled pork. It also sells fresh pasta, soups, imported and domestic meats and cheeses, olives, oils, spices and homemade sauces.
  • Main Street Kitchen, 120 E. Main St., Stoughton: a deli in the historic Brickson Building (also called The Stoughton Store) making subs, specialty sandwiches, homemade soups and salads. It says it has baked its bread and prepared its ingredients daily since 1985.

Bagel shops

  • Bagels Forever, 2947 University Ave.: "Baking Real Bagels Since 1973," according to its site, with New York-style bagels and bagel chips sold at the retail store and shipped around the country.
  • Gotham Bagels, 112 E. Mifflin St.: a family-owned bagel shop that hand-rolls and kettle-boils its bagels and bakes them each morning. Its Madison shop is one of six locations in Chicago and Wisconsin. Signature sandwiches include the Bacon, Egg & Cheddar, the Brighton Beach lox sandwich and the Williamsburg pastrami, with coffee from local roasters. It's a short walk from the Capitol Square.

If you're after loaves and pastries rather than bagel sandwiches, see our bakeries guide.

Downtown and campus

  • Casetta Kitchen and Counter, 222 W. Washington Ave.: a small deli making sandwiches on bread it bakes itself, with soups, sides and chocolate chip cookies.
  • MacTaggart's Market and Deli, 230 W. Lakelawn Pl.: a deli and small market known for breakfast sandwiches and made-to-order deli sandwiches with Boar's Head meats and cheeses, plus housemade bread, pastries and cookies and some grocery items.
  • Carte, 800 Langdon St.: the Wisconsin Union's sandwich and made-to-order salad shop on the first floor of Memorial Union, with grab-and-go items.
  • Conrad's Grill, 563 State St.: home of the "original tot wrap" (tater tots, meat, cheese and sauce rolled in a tortilla), which the shop pitches as a late-night and morning-after option. For more after-dark options, see our late-night food guide.
  • Stadium Takeout, 1517 Monroe St.: "stadium-style eats" near Camp Randall, including Italian beef, Chicago dogs, Philly cheesesteaks, smash burgers and wings, with online ordering. Handy before a Badgers game.

Farm-to-table deli

  • Pasture and Plenty, 2433 University Ave.: a café and deli with a weekly local meal-kit subscription, farm-to-freezer meals and a pantry. It says it is inspired by Wisconsin farmers and producers and focuses on all-natural, plant-based or pasture-raised foods. Dine-in and carryout are both offered.

A local sub chain

Milio's Sandwiches says it started in 1989 at its first location on the UW-Madison campus. It describes its signature bread as the same recipe used since then, baked in each store's ovens every four hours, every day. Our directory lists stores in Madison on East Johnson Street, Regent Street, Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, Junction Road and Commerce Drive, plus Monona, Sun Prairie, Verona, Waunakee and Stoughton.

National chains such as Jimmy John's, Jersey Mike's and Subway also have many Madison-area shops. They're all in our sandwiches and delis category.

Tips for ordering

  • Many delis are small and busy at lunch, especially downtown. Ordering ahead online, where a shop offers it, can save time.
  • Several places here take catering orders for offices and parties. Ask about lead time on the shop's own site.
  • Pair a sandwich with coffee from our coffee shops guide, or look at Wisconsin foods to try for local specialties.

Tips from readers

Know something that would help a neighbor? Be the first to share a tip.

Share a tip

Keep reading

Sources

Rules and dates can change. Check the official source before you rely on them, and suggest a correction if something is out of date.