Skip to content

Shopping

Jewelry stores in Madison

Madison's independent jewelers range from appointment-only design studios to long-running shops that repair and buy as well as sell. This guide groups a selection of them by what each says it offers on its own website, then covers a few official consumer resources for buying and selling. Services change, so confirm with the shop before you bring in a piece. For the wider picture, see where to shop in Madison and our thrift and vintage guide.

Checked against official sources · Updated November 17, 2026

Custom design studios

If you want a ring or pendant made to your own design, start here. Each of these lists custom work on its site.

  • BR Diamond Suite on the Beltline invites visitors to work with its designers on custom engagement rings and custom jewelry, and lists appointments.
  • Soha Diamond Co. in Fitchburg is a by-appointment studio for engagement rings and wedding bands. Its site describes modifying an existing design or creating a new one, with virtual appointments for clients outside the Madison area, and a lifetime service plan that covers repairs.
  • Jewelers on State Street lists custom engagement rings, wedding rings and men's bands, with in-store or virtual appointments on topics such as appraisals and restoration.
  • Jewelers Workshop on Atwood Avenue lists custom engagement rings and consultations, along with repair, restoration and restyling, including ring resizing, stone replacement and antique restoration.
  • Lee Dorn Jewelers on Mineral Point Road lists custom design for rings, bracelets, pendants and earrings, plus repair and restoration, appraisal and engraving.
  • Chalmers Jewelers in Madison and its Middleton store list custom jewelry, bridal jewelry, repair and appraisals. The shop also describes a gem lab that does gemological testing and appraisals under American Gem Society standards.

Handmade and artist jewelry

  • Earth Elements Jewelry on Atwood Avenue says its pieces are one-of-a-kind and handmade in Madison. It also lists custom work, including recycling old stones into new pieces, and repair: ring sizing, chain repair, stone setting and silverware restoration.
  • Studio Jewelers on Regent Street features work by independent artists and designers, plus bridal jewelry. Its site lists custom design and repairs, and says it does not service watches.
  • Metric Forrest Studio on State Street sells handmade beaded and charm jewelry, handcrafted gifts, vintage finds and craft materials, and runs in-studio workshops. It does not list repair. It also fits our gift shops directory.

Repair and everyday fine jewelry

Goodman's Jewelers on State Street lists custom jewelry, jewelry repair and gold buying on its site. For more shops that sell and repair rings, watches and chains, browse the full jewelry stores directory, which also includes jewelers in Middleton, Sun Prairie, Stoughton, Mount Horeb, Oregon and McFarland.

Watch and clock service

Dykman's Time Shop on University Avenue lists watch repair, clock repair, watch crystals and bands, and batteries installed while you wait. Its site also mentions house calls for grandfather clocks. It sells watches and clocks as well. Many general jewelers do not service watches at all, as Studio Jewelers' site notes, so ask before you assume.

Buying, selling and estate pieces

  • Midwest Fine Jewelry & Coin on Monona Drive says it buys and sells gold, silver, coins, bullion and fine jewelry. It lists diamond and estate jewelry and says it helps with entire estates. It offers a free evaluation of items.
  • University Coin & Jewelry in Middleton says it buys diamonds, gold, silver, coin collections, stamps and watches. It sells vintage and estate jewelry, colored gemstones, coins and pre-owned and vintage watches, and lists on-site cleaning, repair and appraisals.

For antique and estate pieces in multi-dealer shops, see the antique malls in our thrift and vintage guide.

Buying tips from the FTC

The Federal Trade Commission's Jewelry Guides are voluntary industry guidance, not law by themselves, but they show what honest descriptions look like. Points worth knowing, as the FTC states them:

  • Gold karat. A gold alloy product may be called "gold" only if the word is preceded by its karat fineness, so "14 Karat Gold" works. A hollow-center item should not be called "solid" gold. Gold plate or gold electroplate claims have their own minimums for the plating.
  • Quality marks. A karat mark should be legible, and under the National Stamping Act the maker or importer must also apply its trademark or name.
  • Lab-grown and imitation diamonds. The FTC says to label them clearly, with terms such as "laboratory-grown" or "simulated" placed close to the word "diamond," not buried in an FAQ.
  • Gemstone treatments. Treatments that are not permanent, or that significantly affect value, should be disclosed at the point of sale and in online ads where you cannot inspect the item.
  • Pearls. "Pearl" alone means a natural pearl. Cultured pearls should say "cultured."

Ask the jeweler for stone and metal details in writing, and for any appraisal terms before you commission one.

Selling gold and jewelry

Wisconsin law, Wis. Stat. 134.71, requires a license for people who buy, sell, receive or exchange secondhand jewelry as a business. The license is applied for through the clerk of the municipality where the dealer's principal place of business is located, and it covers operating anywhere in the state. Exemptions in the statute include garage or yard sales, estate sales, and charitable sales.

The Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection publishes the Property Transaction Record that dealers complete for every transaction. It asks the seller for identification and a signed declaration of ownership. DATCP's form says secondhand jewelry dealers must hold items for at least 21 days, or at least 7 days after an electronic report is submitted. Expect to show ID, and expect a dealer to ask whether the item is yours to sell.

Before selling, get a quote from more than one buyer, ask how the buyer will test and weigh the piece, and ask whether the offer covers the metal only or the whole piece. A jeweler that lists estate buying, such as the two shops above, can tell you what it handles.

Before you go

  • Ask whether a shop does the work on site or sends it out, and how long repairs typically take.
  • Bring any receipts, certificates or earlier appraisals.
  • Check whether a studio is open to walk-ins or works by appointment, since several of the custom studios above are appointment-based.
  • Look through the jewelry stores and gift shops directories for more options near you.

Tips from readers

Know something that would help a neighbor? Be the first to share a tip.

Share a tip

Keep reading

Sources

Rules and dates can change. Check the official source before you rely on them, and suggest a correction if something is out of date.